用户名:
密 码:
忘记密码?
繁体中文  
 
版主:bob
 · 九阳全新免清洗型豆浆机 全美最低
 
恭喜Dialect,他终于反了,尽管比我晚了两年半!
送交者:  2024年09月17日05:06:45 于 [世界时事论坛] 发送悄悄话

戴榕菁

那位我多次提到的Dialect在挣扎了一阵子之后,终于觉悟地喊出了“爱因斯坦对时间的看法是错误的。我们的现代理论陷入了困境。(Einstein was WRONG About Time. Our Modern Theories are in Trouble.)”【[1]】我感觉Dialect这次的大胆反抗应该与我过去一年多里给他的视频的评论有关。

读者会问:给他的视频留言的有成百上千,他又没有向我致谢,凭什么我会感觉他的觉悟与我的评论有关呢?

我的答案是:因为我没有看到任何其他人指出过他的错误,我只看到我一个人一直在(正确地)指出他的错误。

比如,三周前(8月24日)在题为“To Master Physics, First Master The Rotating Coordinate System”的视频【[2]】中Dialect还在宣传广义相对论,而我给他留言道:“To Master Physics, First Understand Physics. That is the way to avoid mathematical pollution.”。

在他6月8日的题为“How Superposition Causes Length Contraction -- And Explains the Principle of Relativity”的视频【[3]】下面我留言道:“1) You are just repeating what the late Jefimenko did more than a decade ago. 2) If you want to say SR is wrong, then just say it..... do not timidly imply it without speaking it out loud. 3) If you do think SR is wrong, then my suggestion: do not even try to step into the swamp of so-called relativistic mass.... that relativistic mass is not real. Accordingly, do not try to maintain the principle of relativity as the first postulate of SR....that principle is very wrong.... 4) If you still feel SR is somewhat correct, then you are wasting time. All in all, if you feel that you need to wake up, just get off the bed, do not stay half wake.”在给该视频留言后,我紧接着写了一篇题为 “难道他是。。。。?”中文博客文章【[4]】,更加详细地分析了给视频中的几个严重的错误。

在他2月3日的题为“Matrix Theory: Relativity Without Relative Space or Time”【[5]】的视频下面,我留言道:“Sad to see your struggle of futile trials, with sympathy though......the only substantial progress you have made in this video is to admit the existence of the so-called "background"......but then you tried hard to confuse it with the Lorentzian ether assumption......Making Einstein's postulate unreal while making what Lorentz called by himself as assumptions to be real cannot save your trouble......Well, while you resist to wake up, the world is still moving on......The sail has passed the STR more than one year ago while we are still watching you struggle in the swirl.......”

在他的2023年11月18日题为“Einstein's Relativity contains a HUGE Loophole. Its Implications Can't Be Ignored.”【[6]】的视频下面我留言道:“good job...but too late and too weak....the one-way constancy of speed of light is NOT just "unverifiable" but has been systematically disproved in "The Fall of Special Relativity and The Absoluteness of Space and Time" more than one year ago, and was summarized in "When philosophy is disparaged" one year ago......as a result, the one-way constancy of speed of light is replaced by the revised postulate of speed of light in vacuum.”。

在他的2023年8月5日的题为“What Time Dilation ACTUALLY Is In Relativity (Hint: It has nothing to do with time)”【[7]】的视频下面我留言道:“What you missed in the closing remarks is this: The Postulate of the Constancy of Speed of Light in Vacuum is Wrong because that postulate suppose the speed of light in vacuum is the same to all observers......The speed of light in constant in vacuum itself, but not to all observers and you need to make this clear!

Now if we forget your closing statement at the end of the video, I can give you this credit that you are smashing special relativity by rebuking the so-called time dilation in this video......if you do not agree with my take of your video, could you come out to clarify it? ”

他回复道“Thanks for watching! The postulate of the invariance of speed of light, according to the Einsteinian interpretation, means the speed of light is constant for all observers, when those observers are measuring it in a vacuum. So if you have two observers in a vacuum traveling at different velocities, they will measure the same speed for any beam of light.

Of course, as Veritasium points out in an excellent video, measuring the speed of light is an impossibility, which makes Einstein's postulate an measurement assumption, not an empirical reality.”

我又回复道“You just touched the critical defect of the philosophy behind special relativity.....as I mentioned in an earlier comment to this video that it is a confusion between the issue of CALIBRATION with the essence.

How you measure the speed is something that can be calibrated which is not the essence of speed......

What we need now is the revised postulate of speed of light in vacuum that you can find online, which states that [The speed of light is constant in vacuum which is not attached to any specific material object, and its value is given by the Maxwell formula c = 1/√(ε˳µ˳), where εo is permittivity in vacuum and μo is permeability in vacuum.]”

我又接着说“Why don't you just spell it out: no time dilation and length contraction due to kinematic motions in nature at all?

Your language used to end the video is too vague......you have been doing this vague business all along in all your relativity related videos so that it is hard for critics like me to hammer or affirm your statements with one clear shot , but in the meantime those who are not of critical might still think that you are upholding special relativity.

What you missed in the closing remarks is this: The Constancy of Speed of Light in Vacuum is Wrong!

Now if we forget your closing statement at the end of the video, I can give you this credit that you are smashing special relativity by rebuking the so-called time dilation in this video......if you do not agree with my take of your video, could you come out to clarify it?”

与之相应地,我又写了三篇与之相关的中文博客文章【[8],[9],[10]】。

讨论

从三周前还在宣传广义相对论到两天前(我今天才看到)终于大声呐喊出“爱因斯坦对时间的看法是错误的。我们的现代理论陷入了困境。(Einstein was WRONG About Time. Our Modern Theories are in Trouble.)”,Dialect终于迈出了他的人生的一大步。尽管对于整个人类文明来说他这已经只是一小步了(因为自两年前我就已经推翻了狭义相对论,并系统地否定了相对论的时空观【[11],[12]】),但仍是非常可喜的一步,因为这代表着在我单枪匹马对抗主流学界两年半之后,Dialect背后的那股强大的维护相对论的势力终于开始内讧了!

其实,早在我于2022年初开始检讨并推翻狭义相对论之前好几年,Dialect就开始对狭义相对论进行反思了,不过他的出发点是想要维护并完善狭义相对论,也就是要对狭义相对论进行修修补补。尽管如来自大洋对岸的某网军小头目(也算是我当初在科大参加研究生杂志的战友)过去两年里反复对我发出的威胁中说的那样,对相对论的质疑属于在上世纪就有了的政治上的错误,感谢上帝的带领,过去两年半里我对狭义相对论系统性的推翻以及对于与狭义相对论相关的包括广义相对论和量子力学在内的20世纪物理学之系统性的反思和批判是前所未有的

我之所以这里要强调我过去两年半里所做的推翻狭义相对论以及对与之相关的20世纪物理学的批判是前所未有的主要有两方面的原因:

其一,要将一切荣耀归于上帝。过去两年半里除了意大利的那位Didier Viel先生曾给我提供过些许帮助之外,我基本上是单枪匹马一人独战连带着网军和科普在内的整个主流学界,而这过程中的每一步(包括在需要的时候就出现了Didier的相关帮助在内)都有来自上帝对我的直接带领。

其二,尽管在上帝的带领下我是第一个系统推翻狭义相对论并系统批判与之相关的20世纪物理学问题的,而且我推翻狭义相对论的工作首先是发表在中文网站,我系统反思批判20世纪物理学的文章也都基本上是首先在中文博客发表然后才将其中一些整理成英文文章,但遗憾的是,华人社会在这次人类物理学的重大转折关头,再一次地落在Dialect他们代表的西方人的后面!几天前,中国物理杂志B(Chinese Physics B)刚刚又拒绝了我关于薛定谔对其著名方程的推导错误的文章【[13]】。


0%(0)
0%(0)
缂備焦顨愰幏锟� 闂佸憡鐔幏锟� (闂婎偄娲ら幊姗€鍩€椤掆偓椤︾敻濡撮敓锟�): 闁诲海顣幏锟� 闂佹椿鍣幏锟� (闂婎偄娲ら幊姗€鍩€椤掆偓椤︾敻濡撮敓锟�): 濠电偛顦崝宀勫船娴犲妫橀柟娈垮枟閺嗗繘鏌熸潏鐐
标 题 (必选项):
内 容 (选填项):

婵犵數濮烽弫鎼佸磻濞戙垺鍋嬮柛娑卞灠缁躲倕鈹戦悩瀹犲缂佺姵宀搁弻鏇㈠醇濠垫劖笑闂佸憡鍔忛崑鎾绘⒒娴h櫣甯涢柟鍝デ归湁濡炲瀛╅崗婊堟煃瑜濋幏锟�
闂傚倷娴囬褏鈧稈鏅濈划娆撳箳濡も偓妗呴梺缁樺姉閺佸摜绮堟繝鍥ㄧ叆闁绘洖鍊圭€氾拷
闂傚倷娴囬褏鈧稈鏅濈划娆撳箳濡炲皷鍋撻崘顔煎窛闁煎壊鍏涘Ч妤呮⒑鐠恒劌娅愰柟鍑ゆ嫹
实用资讯
北美最大最全的折扣机票网站
美国名厂保健品一级代理,花旗参,维他命,鱼油,卵磷脂,30天退货保证.买百免邮.
一周点击热帖 更多>>
1 闂佽 鍋撻柟绋跨凹缁楀鎮橀悙鈺佷壕閻庢鍠掗崑鎾趁归崗鐓庣劰闁逞屽墯缁矁銇愰悢铏瑰崥閻庯絺鏅濋鍗炩槈閹垮啩绨烽柤鍨灦瀵板嫰顢欓崗澶婁壕婵犲灚鎸剧壕鐓庘槈閺冩挻瀚� 婵犮垹鐖㈤崘鈺冾洭婵犵鈧啿鈧綊骞戦敐鍡愪粓闁跨噦鎷�
2 闂佸搫鍊稿ú锕€危閹寸姷涓嶉柍褜鍓熷畷锝囨嫚瑜忕粣妤冪磼鐎n亜鏆辨繛瀛樺姉閳ь剛顢婂▔娑樷槈閻㈠憡鍋ㄧ€瑰嫭澹嗗В鈧繝闈涘€搁崯鍨暦閿燂拷 婵犮垹鐖㈤崘鈺冾洭婵犵鈧啿鈧綊骞戦敐鍡愪粓闁跨噦鎷�
3 缂備礁澧介弲顐も偓鐟扮-閹瑰嫰骞嬮悜鍡楀Ρ闁哄鏅滅粙鎴﹀矗閸℃稑绀傞柛娆愶耿閻涙挸鈽夐幘璇″敽缂佺姷鍠栭弫宥夋晸閿燂拷 婵犮垹鐖㈤崘鈺冾洭婵犵鈧啿鈧綊骞戦敐鍡愪粓闁跨噦鎷�
4 闂佸搫顦鎼佸储閻樺樊鍤曢柛婵嗗閻撳倿骞栫€涙ɑ绀冩俊鍙夋倐楠炩偓閹煎瓨绻勯悿鍕叏濠靛﹤鍚规繛鍫熷灴閺佸秹鏁撻敓锟� 闁荤姴顑呴崯鈺冩濠靛绀冩繛鎴炵懄閺夛拷
5 婵炴垶鎼╅崢濂稿矗閿熺姴绾ч柛鎰ㄦ櫆閻忓秹鏌涘▎妯虹仴闁稿繑蓱濞煎繘鎮欓鈧悘鍥р攽鎺抽崕鍗炵暦濡ゅ懏鏅慨妯虹-濡叉垿鎮楃€涖們鍊ら崬鎾煏閸☆厽瀚� 闁荤姴顑呴崯鈺冩濠靛绀冩繛鎴炵懄閺夛拷
6 闂佸憡鐟╅ˉ鎾光叿婵炴垶鎼╅崢鐓幟瑰Δ鍐當妞ゆ垼娉曢鍗炍涢敐鍛棤婵炲牊鍨垮畷鈥澄旈崨顏勪壕婵﹩鍓欑憴锕傛煟濡炵粯娅堥悗姘炬嫹 婵犮垹鐖㈤崘鈺冾洭婵犵鈧啿鈧綊骞戦敐鍡愪粓闁跨噦鎷�
7 婵炲鍘ч敃銉ワ耿閺囩姭鍋撻崷顓炰粶濠殿喖绻樺畷娆掔疀閹剧补鍋撻妷鈺佺闁绘柨顨庨崬鍝勨槈閹垮啫骞栨繛瀛橆殜瀹曟岸鍩¢崘鈺傚Ρ闂佹寧绋戞總鏃傚緤妤e啫瀚夐柨鐕傛嫹 婵犮垹鐖㈤崘鈺冾洭婵犵鈧啿鈧綊骞戦敐鍡愪粓闁跨噦鎷�
8 濡ょ姷鍋涢悿鍥Υ閳ь剙鈽夐幘鎶筋€楀ù鐘茬摠閹梹顦版惔銏㈡殸闂佸搫鐗滈崑鍌滅箔濡吋鍠嗛柨鐕傛嫹 闁荤姴顑呴崯鈺冩濠靛绀冩繛鎴炵懄閺夛拷
9 婵$偠顕栭崜姘跺蓟婢舵劕绀傞悗锝呭缁€澶愭煙椤掆偓缁ㄨ偐绮婚悙鍝勭煑闁割偆鍟块崑鎾诲磼濞嗘垵鏅╅梺鎸庣〒閸犲秶妲愰幍顔藉仏妞ゆ劧鑵归弨鎶芥⒑椤愶絽濮囬柛銈忔嫹 闁荤姴顑呴崯鈺冩濠靛绀冩繛鎴炵懄閺夛拷
10 婵炴垶鎹佸銊у垝閸喓鈻曢柛顐g矋閻晫绱掗銉ュ惞婵炲牊鍨垮畷閿嬶紣娴h櫣孝闂佸搫瀚烽崹浼村Φ婢跺濯村璺烘憸閻熸繈鏌ょ€圭姵顥夌€殿喚鍏橀幆鍐晸閿燂拷 婵犮垹鐖㈤崘鈺冾洭婵犵鈧啿鈧綊骞戦敐鍡愪粓闁跨噦鎷�
一周回复热帖
1 闂備焦鍎崇换鎰潩閿旇姤鍎熷┑鐘插暟閳绘棃鏌涢妷鎴濇噽娴硷拷 缂傚倷鐒﹂弻銊ワ耿闁稁鏁傚┑鍌溓圭粻浼存煙鐎电ǹ顎岄柡鍡樼矒閺屾盯顢曢浣割伓 濠电偞鍨堕幐鎼佀囬悧鍫滅箚闁归棿绀佺粈鍡涙煃瑜濋幏锟�
2 濠电偞鍨堕幐鍝ョ矓瀹曞洦顫曢柟娈垮枟婵ジ鏌嶇悰鈥充壕缂備讲鈧啿顏繛鐓庮煼楠炲鈹戠€n偄鐨哄┑鐐村灦閹尖晠宕i崘顔肩劦妞ゆ帊鐒﹂ˉ鍫ユ煃瑜滈崗姗€宕戦幘瓒佸綊鏁愯箛鏂款伓 濠电偞鍨堕幐鎼佀囬悧鍫滅箚闁归棿绀佺粈鍡涙煃瑜濋幏锟�
3 濠电姰鍨奸~澶嬪垔娴犲鏁囬柟绋挎捣閳绘梹銇勯幘璺轰粶鐟滅増鐟ラ湁婵犲﹤妫欓鐘绘煏閸モ晛浠遍柡灞界墦婵℃悂濡烽敃鈧埀顒佺墵閺岋綁濮€閿濆棜鍚傚┑顔炬嚀椤︻垶锝為姀銏″闁惧浚鍋嗗┃鍕煟閻樺啿濮傞柛銊嚙閳绘捇骞嬮悙娈挎锤闂佽法鍣﹂幏锟� kdw
4 闂備礁鎲¢崹鐢垫崲閹烘鐓熼柨婵嗩槸鐎氬顭跨捄渚Ш闁活厼妫楅埥澶愬棘鐠恒劌鈪遍梺杞伴檷閸婃繈寮澶嬫櫢闁跨噦鎷� 闂佽崵濮撮鍛村疮閳哄啯顐芥繝闈涱儏缁€鍐╃箾閹寸偟鎳勯柡澶涙嫹
5 闂備礁鎲$敮鈺呭磻閸屾粌鍨濋幖娣灮椤╃兘鏌涘☉鍗炵仭缂佺姵鐟╅弻銈嗭紣娴h櫣鐛㈤梺宕囨嚀閻楀﹦绮欐径瀣劅闁靛牆鍊告禍鎯归敐鍛喐闁绘稈鏅犻弻锝夊Ω閵夈儺浼€闂佺ǹ楠哥紞濠傤潖婵犳碍鏅搁柨鐕傛嫹 濠电姰鍨归悥銏ゅ礃閳哄喚娲┑鐘殿暯閳ь剙鍟块埀顒€缍婇獮鎴︽晲閸℃劒绮撻梺璺ㄥ櫐閹凤拷
6 闂備礁鎲¢悷鈺吽夐幘鍏夊徔濠电偞鍨堕幖鈺呭储閻撳篃鐟拔旈崘顏嗙暥濡炪倖鍨煎▔鏇㈩敂閸楃倣娑㈡晲閸涱噮妫ゅ┑鐐茬墛閸ㄥ灝鐣烽垾婢勬棃宕ㄩ鍕濠殿喗锕╅崜娆戞喆閿曞倹鐓熸俊鐐电帛濞呭牓鎮楀鐐 濠电姰鍨归悥銏ゅ礃閳哄喚娲┑鐘殿暯閳ь剙鍟块埀顒€缍婇獮鎴︽晲閸℃劒绮撻梺璺ㄥ櫐閹凤拷
7 闂備礁鎼ú鈺傜珶閸儱绠垫い蹇撴閻掑﹪鏌i幘铏崳妞ゅ繑濞婂濠氬焵椤掑嫬鍨傛い鏃囨閳ь剛鏁婚弻锝夊Ω閵夈儺浠煎┑鐘欌偓閸嬫捇姊洪崫鍕珔闁瑰嚖鎷� 濠电姰鍨归悥銏ゅ礃閳哄喚娲┑鐘殿暯閳ь剙鍟块埀顒€缍婇獮鎴︽晲閸℃劒绮撻梺璺ㄥ櫐閹凤拷
8 濠电偞鍨堕幖鈺呭储婵傜ǹ鐭楅柨鐔哄Т缁€鍌涙叏濮楀棗澧柛鐘叉噹闇夋繝濠傛噹閸斿鏌¢崱娆忔灁缂侇噯绲鹃幏鍛存惞閻熼偊妫冨┑鐐村灦閹告挳宕戦幘瓒佺懓饪伴崘顏冭檸闂佽鍠楃划宥囩矙婢舵劕鍐€闁挎梻鏅┃鍕煟閻樺弶鐭楅柣鎺炵畱鍗遍柨鐕傛嫹 濠电姰鍨归悥銏ゅ礃閳哄喚娲┑鐘殿暯閳ь剙鍟块埀顒€缍婇獮鎴︽晲閸℃劒绮撻梺璺ㄥ櫐閹凤拷
9 闂備焦鍎崇换鎰潩閿旇姤鍎熷┑鐘插暟閳绘棃鏌涢妷鎴濇噽娴硷拷 闂備焦鎮堕崕鑼矙閹存繄鏆﹂柛鏇ㄥ灠缁€鍌涖亜閹板墎鎮煎ù婊愮秮閺岀喖妫冨☉鍗炲壉閺夆晜绻勯埀顒侇問閸n垶骞忛敓锟� 濠电姰鍨归悥銏ゅ礃閳哄喚娲┑鐘殿暯閳ь剙鍟块埀顒€缍婇獮鎴︽晲閸℃劒绮撻梺璺ㄥ櫐閹凤拷
10 濠电偞鍨堕幑浣割浖閵娧冨灊闁割偆鍠撻埢鏇㈡煕椤愶絿鐭嬮柣顏嗘櫕缁辨帡顢曢妷銉ユ優濠电偛鐗婇崹鍨暦闁垮绱eù锝堟瀛濋梻浣告惈鐎氱兘宕规导鏉懳﹀璺侯儐婵潙顭跨捄鐑樻喐闁荤喐绻堥弻銈団偓鍦У椤ュ鈧鍠氶崗姗€骞嗛崘顔芥櫢闁跨噦鎷� 濠电姰鍨归悥銏ゅ礃閳哄喚娲┑鐘殿暯閳ь剙鍟块埀顒€缍婇獮鎴︽晲閸℃劒绮撻梺璺ㄥ櫐閹凤拷
历史上的今天:回复热帖
2023: 习近平必须暴毙,因为他挡了和平演变之
2023: 七绝 题照(2051)莫言闭嘴到今朝
2022: 某人内部讲话
2022: 中西医结合才是中国的方向
2021: “恶法非法”还是“恶法亦法”?
2021: 空气过滤:水洗
2020: 逻辑捉妖集(3)社会主义是大锅饭
2020: 台海之战后的世界格局
2019: 基金不给力 钓鱼来解气
2019: “郭媒体”依靠赞助