用户名:
密 码:
忘记密码?
繁体中文  
 
版主:x-file
 · 九阳全新免清洗型豆浆机 全美最低
 
中,美, 印, 三国总债务比较
送交者:  2024年09月17日07:33:55 于 [世界游戏论坛] 发送悄悄话


中国总债务。 14.8 万亿美元, 占GDP 82%

美国总债务。 33万亿美元。 占GDP 120%

印度总债务。 6.5万亿美元,占GDP 182%

If  India's external debt was $663.8 billion, why it needs to pay $130 as interest?


ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT

India's external debt of $663.8 billion represents the total amount borrowed from foreign sources, including other governments, international financial institutions, and foreign commercial banks. However, the $130 billion interest payment reflects not just interest on external debt but also interest payments on domestic debt.

The Indian government borrows heavily from both domestic and foreign lenders, with the majority of its debt being internal, raised through bonds and loans within India. Domestic borrowing is substantial and often carries high-interest costs. The government issues various types of bonds to finance its fiscal deficit, which accrues significant interest liabilities.

As a result, even though external debt is $663.8 billion, the total debt (both domestic and external) is much higher, leading to annual interest payments of around $130 billion(

).


In summary, the large interest payment is primarily due to a combination of domestic and external borrowing, not just the external debt alone.

You said:
Internal debt This is the debt owed to lenders within India and makes up about 89.8% of public debt. External debt This is the debt owed to foreign lenders and makes up about 10.2% of public debt.
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT

You are correct: internal debt makes up the bulk of India’s public debt, accounting for about 89.8%, while external debt constitutes the remaining 10.2%. This division means that India’s debt servicing costs are largely driven by internal borrowing, not external debt.

Breakdown:

  • Internal Debt: This includes debt owed to domestic lenders, primarily through the issuance of government bonds. The government borrows from domestic financial institutions, public sector banks, insurance companies, and private investors. Since internal debt dominates the total public debt, most of India's interest payments go toward servicing this portion. Domestic interest rates also tend to be higher, contributing to the significant interest payment burden.

  • External Debt: This includes debt owed to foreign lenders, international institutions, and foreign governments. It makes up a smaller portion of the overall debt, and typically, interest rates on foreign loans are lower due to favorable terms from international lenders.

Given that the total public debt is composed mostly of internal debt, it’s the primary reason India’s interest payments are so high—$130 billion annually. Even though external debt stands at $663.8 billion, domestic borrowing at higher interest rates significantly contributes to this large interest payment.

This distinction highlights that India's fiscal challenges come not just from external debt, but from the scale and cost of domestic borrowing as well.

You said:
external debt is $663.8 billion, which is 10.2% of the total debt, so 663.8/0.102, total debt is 6507.8
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT

Your calculation is essentially correct. If external debt of $663.8 billion represents 10.2% of India's total public debt, the total debt can be calculated as:

Total Debt=663.80.1026507.8 billion dollars ext{Total Debt} = frac{663.8}{0.102} approx 6507.8 ext{ billion dollars}

So, India's total public debt is approximately $6.5 trillion. This includes both internal debt (89.8% of the total) and external debt (10.2%).

This high overall debt burden, coupled with domestic borrowing at higher interest rates, is why India faces such significant interest payment obligations, including the reported $130 billion in annual debt servicing.

You said:
what is the total (internal debt and external debt) of the US , and China?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT



As of 2024:

  • United States: The total public debt is approximately $33 trillion, with external debt making up around $26.5 trillion. Most of this debt is held by U.S. citizens, institutions, and foreign countries like China and Japan.

  • China: The total debt of China is more complex due to the country's unique financial structure. As of early 2024, China's external debt was reported at approximately $1.3 trillion. Its internal debt (domestic debt) is significantly larger, with estimates suggesting China's total debt is around $14.8 trillion. This includes both government and corporate debt.

These figures highlight the vast differences in the financial structures of the two largest economies in the world.



0%(0)
0%(0)
缁楋拷 閸氾拷 (韫囧懘鈧銆�): 鐎碉拷 閻拷 (韫囧懘鈧銆�): 濞夈劌鍞介弬鎵暏閹达拷
标 题 (必选项):
内 容 (选填项):

婵犵數鍋涢悧鍛緤婵犳艾绠氶柕鍫濐槸閸愨偓闂佺粯鎸稿ù椋庢兜閳э拷
闂佽瀛╃粙鎺楀Φ閻愮數绀婇柨鐕傛嫹
闂佽瀛╃粙鎺椼€冮崨鑸汗闁跨噦鎷�
实用资讯
北美最大最全的折扣机票网站
美国名厂保健品一级代理,花旗参,维他命,鱼油,卵磷脂,30天退货保证.买百免邮.
一周点击热帖 更多>>
1 瑜版挷琚卞畝鍛婃付缂佸牏绮烘稉鈧弮璁圭礉鐠囪渹绗夌憰浣镐海鐟佸懏鍎� 閻忣偅鐖�
2 閳ユ粓鈹嶉柅锟�+濞屸剝鏁归垾婵撶磼閻濐厼鍟橀垾婊呭盀鐠佲檧鈧繐绱濇す锟� 閻忣偅鐖�
3 娑旂姾绻庨獮鍏呯瑢閻楄婀曢弲顔荤窗鐠嬪牆鎮楅敍宀€鈻堥崷鐔兼6妫帮拷 閻忣偅鐖�
4 J36閺堝搫銇旈崣顖欎簰閺€鎹愮箻閸橈拷1.5缁磭娲垮鍕畱閻拷 閻忣偅鐖�
5 瀹告繃娅橀敍姘灉濠娐ゅ壋鐎涙劙鍏橀弰顖欒厬閸ユ枻绱濆▽锛勨敄閹硷拷 閻忣偅鐖�
6 娑撯偓鐎靛湱顫栫€涳箑銇嬫俊璇差洤娴f洘鎸伴崝銊ょ瑯閻e瞼鈻堥崷鐔哥壐 閻忣偅鐖�
7 閸欐澘瀵虫總鍐差劉閻銇囬梽鍡窗閹存垼鍒€娑撳﹣绨℃禒鈧稊鍫熸 閻忣偅鐖�
8 瀹告繃娅橀懕鏃傛礃濮濓絽婀崚鍡楃┛缁傜粯鐎介敍宀冪箹娑撳秳绮庢稉锟� 閻忣偅鐖�
9 閸忓厖绨垾婊€浜掗幁鎺撴袱娑撹桨鑵戦崡鎷岀珶閻e备鈧繄娈戦惇瀣《 閻忣偅鐖�
10 闂囧綊娲�-15E閻㈢喍楠囩痪鍖$礉缂冩洝顫嗛弴婵嗗帨閿涳拷 閻忣偅鐖�
一周回复热帖
1 閸楁澘瀹崇€广垺婧€閸х姵鐦夊鑼跺毀133娴滄椽浜i梾鎾呯礉濞夈垽鐓� 閻忣偅鐖�
2 妤傛ê绻旈崙顖ょ窗閸忓厖绨稉顓炲祪鏉堝湱鏅敍灞炬Ц閺冭泛鈧瑨绐� 閻忣偅鐖�
3 濮濄倖顐煎鏉戠唨閺傤垰娼堕崘娑樻暛妞ゅ湱娲伴敍灞炬Ц瀵邦喖顩炬担锟� 閻忣偅鐖�
4 閺堟繃鏌熼幏鎺撴暪閻楄婀曢弲顔荤堪缁楁柧淇婇敍鐔烘鐎诡偄娲栨惔锟� 閻忣偅鐖�
5 閳ユ粎鐖径绮光偓婵呬簰閸氾拷 閺堟繈鐭炴す閬嶁偓鎰煂閹佃埖顒� 閻忣偅鐖�
6 閻楄婀曢弲顔煎弿闂堛垺娈忛崑锟�12閸ヨ棄鍙曞鎴g箻閸忋儳绶ㄩ崶锟� 閻忣偅鐖�
7 閹剝绁婚柅姘辩礆閿涳拷20閸氬秴褰村﹢鐐毌鏉╂稑鍘疯ぐ鎾崇湰閳ワ拷 閻忣偅鐖�
8 闂囧綊娲�-15E閻㈢喍楠囩痪鍖$礉缂冩洝顫嗛弴婵嗗帨閿涳拷 閻忣偅鐖�
9 缂囧簼绱掗幎杈ㄢ偓顭掔窗閹存垳婊戦弰搴㈡娑撯偓瀵偓婵婀弽姝屼粵 閻忣偅鐖�
10 閹靛骸鎼辩純妤€鈻嬮敍姘跺€嬬拠宄版躬缂囧酣浼冮柆鍥︾瑝閸忣剛娈戞稉锟� 閻忣偅鐖�
历史上的今天:回复热帖
2022: 上海合作组织成员国元首理事会撒马尔罕
2022: 刘宗义:印度做对了什么?
2021: 专家:航天员重返地球风险高 首次在东风
2021: 中国常驻维也纳联合国代表:美英协助澳
2020: 伊朗教授拒绝充当FBI间谍后,又被“诱骗
2020: 印度一个退役旅长说,印度希望和平但是
2019: 新节目刚官宣5天,美国喜剧人就因辱华言