用户名:
密 码:
忘记密码?
繁体中文  
 
版主:黑木崖
 · 九阳全新免清洗型豆浆机 全美最低
 
俄军在俄白军演中电子阻塞能力震惊北约
送交者:  2017年11月25日02:56:35 于 [世界军事论坛] 发送悄悄话

Lessons from Zapad – jamming, NATO and the future of Belarus

 By: Aaron Mehta  

   2 days ago 32240 Russian President Vladimir Putin, center, Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu, left, and Chief of the General Staff of the Russian Armed Forces Valery Gerasimov, right, watch a military exercise at a training ground at the Luzhsky Range, near St. Petersburg, Russia, on Sept. 18, 2017. (Mikhail Klimentyev/Sputnik/Kremlin Pool Photo via AP) 

 WASHINGTON – The bi-annual Zapad military exercise, jointly run by Russia and Belarus, was closely watched this September by Western nations. And while there were some concerns that the movement could be a cover for aggressive action from Moscow, the exercise was completed without incident – and for those outside the region, largely faded from memory. But for close NATO watchers, and especially the Baltic nations and Poland, seeing Russian forces operating up close provided some interesting threads to follow in the coming months. 

“I think we gained some insight into things we knew they could do, but it just largely refreshed us in terms of knowing this is something that we have to work on,” said Jim Townsend, a longtime Pentagon Europe expert now with the Center for a New American Security think tank. At the same time, “I don’t think we saw something that was shocking,” Townsend said. “We didn’t see a new capability, we just saw a lot of things that we’ve always known about and we worry about.” Col. Kaupo Rosin, Estonia’s head of military intelligence, agreed that there was nothing truly shocking to come out of Zapad, but highlighted a few key takeaways from the event that his nation would be thinking through going forward. The first big takeaway, Rosin told Defense News in a November interview, was what Russia was doing in the electronic warfare space, and specifically how Zapad was done in a largely EW-hostile environment, apparently reflecting how Russia excepts to have to deal with a Western assault. 

“The amount of jamming of their own troops surprised me. It was at a level we haven’t seen. And they did it in the different branches, so land force, air force. That definitely surprised us,” Rosin said. Estonian official: Cyber must be part of core military education Estonian official: Cyber must be part of core military education A top Estonian military officer is worried about NATO nations train for cyber battle. By: Aaron Mehta Sign up for our Daily News Roundup The top Defense News stories of the daySubscribe Under that status quo, the combined Russian forces had to fall back on maps and local knowledge of the Belarusian region they were stationed in. 

That helps train in two areas: building knowledge that could be vital for local forces defending against a Western incursion in the region, and getting used to what kind of electronic warfare NATO forces could bring to bear. As a result, NATO should think of other means for disrupting Russian communications, rather than just jamming, Rosin said. “It probably includes some cyber activities but we have to use them,” he noted. “Then of course we have to think, how do we protect our own communications? What are our solutions in cases of electronic warfare that then kick in?” And the fact Russia could jam its own troops so easily shows they have advanced capabilities that could be turned on NATO forces in a time of conflict. And while that might not be a problem for Estonian forces, it could complicated the alliance being able to coordinate efforts. “As a small country, we can still command troops using a paper map. We have done that always. So, for us I think it’s not that big of a problem,” Rosin noted. “The problem will kick in with reinforcement troops from other countries which are far away from home, and probably in higher echelons. When we are talking about the NATO command structure or different staff, then I think the problem will kick in.” 

A second lesson from Zapad is the vital nature of speed for the NATO alliance. If Russia made a move through Belarus towards the Baltic states, could the alliance military get to the front quickly enough for it to matter? “That’s always the question. The Russians have always the advantage of the time and space and troops,” Rosin noted, adding that a focus for the alliance in the coming year will be to figure out legal ways for NATO forces to move more quickly across nations’ borders. While Estonia has made it so allied forces can move in within 24 hours, other nations take longer. 

“The rapid transport is very, very important including sea, air, and land, of course. And of course, the more troops we have for already in the peace time, the less we have to transport in the war time,” he said. A third takeaway from Zapad is the role and importance of Belarus, which housed the official part of the Zapad exercise. Rosin said it was psychologically, militarily and politically vital for Russia to keep Belarus under its umbrella. “If it’s achieved without any military action, it’s okay for Russia,” Rosin said, but he warned that “if there is a serious threat, that Belorussia will somehow slide away from their point of view, [Russia] will definitely use” military force to keep Minsk under its control.

 And should that happen, Belarus is likely on its own, Rosin acknowledged. “I don’t think that anybody will come to help Belarus in that case militarily. We will definitely all be very concerned and so on,” he said. “But there will be no — at least this is my current assessment in November 2017, is that there will be no military action [from NATO] if Russia conducts military action in Belarus.” For Townsend, though, the biggest takeaway is to remember that Zapad is an important military exercise—and likely nothing more. “We spin ourselves up and we give them these propaganda victories, and they don’t even have to do anything,” Townsend said. “They go ‘boo’ and everyone jumps and runs around, and we can’t let them do that. “I think next time we have to be cool and calm and say ‘Lets just be cool here.’ They’ve been doing Zapad for many years and no one paid attention until recently. So, let’s not overreact, be proportionate, be cool, and not lose our minds.”    

0%(0)
0%(0)
缁楋拷 閸氾拷 (韫囧懘鈧銆�): 鐎碉拷 閻拷 (韫囧懘鈧銆�): 濞夈劌鍞介弬鎵暏閹达拷
标 题 (必选项):
内 容 (选填项):

濠电姷鏁告慨鐑藉极閹间礁纾绘繛鎴欏灪閸嬪鏌涘☉鍗炵仩缂佽翰鍊曢埞鎴︽偐鐎圭姴顥濈紓浣哄У瀹€鎼佸蓟閺囥垹閱囨繝鍨姈绗戦梻浣告啞閸斿繘宕戦幘缁樷拻濞达綀娅g敮娑㈡煙閸濄儑褰掓箒婵$偛顑呯€涒晠宕楀⿰鍫熺厓鐟滄繈骞忛敓锟�
闂傚倸鍊峰ù鍥敋瑜忛埀顒佺▓閺呮繄鍒掑▎鎾崇婵°倐鍋撳鍛存⒑缂佹ê濮夐柡浣告憸缁牊绻濋崶銊у弳闂佺粯娲栭崐鍦偓姘炬嫹
闂傚倸鍊峰ù鍥敋瑜忛埀顒佺▓閺呮繄鍒掑▎鎾崇婵$偛鐨烽崑鎾诲礃椤旂厧绐涢梺鐓庡閸忔稑效濡ゅ懏鈷戦悹鎭掑妼濞呮劙鏌熼崙銈嗗
实用资讯
北美最大最全的折扣机票网站
美国名厂保健品一级代理,花旗参,维他命,鱼油,卵磷脂,30天退货保证.买百免邮.
一周点击热帖 更多>>
1 姒涙垶顒熸竟顐︹敋閸掑府绱掗崗銊︽煀濮濓拷-20娴滎喚娴夐敍宀€绶ㄩ崶锟� eastwest
2 婢额亞鐛婇悞璁圭磼閸╁啫寮风€规ê顓洪柌鍥枠娑擃厼娴楃痪銏℃-9 eastwest
3 娑撯偓婢圭檼-POP閻愬憡鏌囨禍鍡涚叐閸ヨ姤鏋冮崠鏍ㄦ付閸氬海娈戦懘锟� eastwest
4 瀹告潙鍟楅崜宥呭棘鐠嬪鏆遍敍姘毊閽€钘夊祪鎼达腹鈧粓妯€妞嬪簶鈧拷 eastwest
5 娑撳鍦洪惄鎾偓姘吂濮圭喎褰涢敍灞筋嚠娑擃厼娴楅弸浣疯礋闁插秷顩� eastwest
6 濮濓絽绱$憗鍛槵闁劑妲﹂敍锟� zt eastwest
7 閸楁澘瀹抽幈灞肩啊閿涙岸妫舵0妯瑰紬闁插稄绱濆锝勭瑢娑擃厼娴楅幒锟� eastwest
8 娑擃厼娴楁稉杞扮秿閺冪姵纭堕幍鈺佺炊閸掓壆绱栭崠妤嬬礉閹垫捇鈧艾宓� eastwest
9 娑斿澧犳0鍕枅閻ㄥ嫯绻曢崑蹇庣箽鐎瑰牅绨℃稉鈧悙骞库偓锟� 閸愬秵娼� eastwest
10 缂囧骸娴楅幆鏂モ偓妯诲ⅵ娑撳鈧瑤鑵戦崶鑺ユ¥娴滅儤婧€閿涚喍绗夐崣锟� eastwest
一周回复热帖
1 婵″倷缍嶇€电銈块弬閫涘悏閸欒尪顔戞稉鈧崜鎴濈殱閸犲绱� eastwest
2 娑旂喕顕╂稉杞扮矆娑斿牆绻€妞よ寮界€靛厜鈧粏銈块弬閫涘悏閸欒尪顔� eastwest
3 閼诲繗浠堢紘搴℃禇閻ㄥ嫯鈥滅拹銉ゅ瘜鐟曚焦妲搁崚璺哄娑撳秷顢戞潻锟� eastwest
4 鏉╂瑤閲滈幁璺哄А閸忓牅绶ラ敍灞惧灉娴狀剙鍠呮稉宥堝厴缂佹瑨绉洪崡锟� eastwest
5 閵嗘劒绺块弬鐟版礀閹插爼瀵楅妴鎴犵癌111.閸楁澘瀹抽惃鍕┾偓灞炬緟 eastwest
6 娑撳啩绔锋禍瀣綁閸撳稄绱濇稉顓炴禇濮f柧绱涢張妤冪崼閸ュ﹣绔撮惂锟� eastwest
7 娑擃厼娴楁稉杞扮秿閺冪姵纭堕幍鈺佺炊閸掓壆绱栭崠妤嬬礉閹垫捇鈧艾宓� eastwest
8 閻楄婀曢弲顔剧崐閻掕泛顓虹敮鍐洣鐎电绻橀崣锝堝祩閸濅礁绶涢弨锟� eastwest
9 娑撹桨绮堟稊鍫ュ亝娑斿牆顦挎禍鍝勬躬妤犲倷绱涢張锟� 閸楁潙绶㈢亸鎴︾崑 eastwest
10 娑擃厼娴楅崪灞藉絺鏉堟儳娴楃€规儼绻曢張澶夌矆娑斿牆妯婄捄锟� eastwest
历史上的今天:回复热帖
2016: 中微子传奇(上篇,4):(B)来自于粒
2016: 评论:用于导弹拦截的天基传感器层
2015: 本月是爱因斯坦相对论诞生一百年,转一
2015: 土耳其击落俄战机事件的缘由、前景和启
2014: 张召忠:中国用成千上万铁块整合成舰 不
2014: 吴建民打压民族主义,反民主,违民意,
2013: 深度:防空识别区内中日较量的武器会有
2013: 再贴:历年军坛ID大全(中文版)
2012: BBC: 日本对中国印象不佳人数刷新记录
2012: 沈飞集团董事长罗阳:用生命换来歼-15完